Defunding Obamacare: Questions & Answers, Excuses & Responses

If you have not written to your congressmen, please do so and request they defund Obamacare (or call them).  I have included 2 letters I have sent if you would like something to steal ideas from.  The letters are similiar but adjusted depending on who I was writing to.

....................................................
      

POLICY AND TECHNICAL

“What do you mean by defunding Obamacare?”

Defunding Obamacare means attaching a legislative rider to a “must pass” bill (debt limit, annual spending bill, etc.) that 1) prohibits any funds from being spent on any activities to implement or enforce Obamacare; 2) rescinds any unspent balances that have already been appropriated for implementation; and 3) turns off the exchange subsidy and new Medicaid spending that are on auto-pilot.

“There is no such thing as defunding Obamacare.”

That is a false statement.  Congressmen who assert this are either asserting that funding is not being spent to implement Obamacare (false) or that a defund amendment cannot technically be executed (again, false).  Defunding Obamacare can be done, and it has been attempted by the House of Representatives recently.  For instance, in 2011, after gaining the majority, the Republican House included such a defunding provision on the continuing spending resolution (HR 1) when the bill first passed the House.  The provision was later discarded in negotiations with the President and the Senate, but the effort began with promise.      

“What is the urgency to defund Obamacare now?” 

On January 1, 2014, Obamacare’s new main entitlements—the Medicaid expansion and the exchange subsidies—are  scheduled to take effect.  Open enrollment for both programs begins on October 1, 2013, at the start of the new fiscal year.  According to the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the federal government will spend $48 billion in 2014—and nearly $1.8 trillion through 2023—on these new entitlement programs.  Also on January 1, Americans will be forced by their government to buy a product—health insurance—for the first time ever.  Individuals and families who don’t comply will be penalized by tax penalties administered through the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).  The Obama Administration has requested over $400 million in funding and nearly 2,000 bureaucrats for the IRS to implement the individual mandate and 46 other statutory provisions in the law.  Within the Administration, the blizzard of Obamacare rules and regulations continues apace.  Regulators have now written over 20,000 pages of Obamacare-related rules and notices in the Federal Register.  Many of these regulations will increase the cost of insurance; CBO concluded Obamacare would raise individual health insurance premiums by $2,100 per year.

“Isn’t defunding Obamacare impossible because most of the funding is ‘mandatory’ (or on ‘auto-pilot’) and cannot be amended via the annual appropriations process?”

No.  According to the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service (CRS), the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the IRS, “will incur substantial administrative costs to implement the law’s private insurance reforms and its changes to the federal health care programs.”  And while Obamacare provided $1 billion in mandatory implementation funding when it was enacted, HHS projects that this is largely spent.  According to CRS, Obamacare “administrative costs will have to be funded through the annual discretionary appropriations.”  Furthermore, annual appropriations bills routinely carry funding limitations to block all sorts of activities (for example, the Hyde Amendment), as well make changes to mandatory spending.  These latter provisions are called “changes in mandatory program spending” (CHIMPS).  Even if these riders were not so common-place, the stakes of so many provisions of Obamacare scheduled to take effect would present grounds for an exception.

“Isn’t defunding impossible because there is not a specific funding stream for Obamacare?  Funding is embedded throughout the federal government and not specifically designated.

No.  Congress is aware of all of the programs that fund Obamacare because CRS has provided such a list and the Appropriations Committees are well-versed in the funding intricacies of the law.  However, a blanket prohibition against funding all activities associated with implementing the law is all that is needed to halt implementation.  Each program does not have to be specifically defunded.  

POLITICAL AND STRATEGIC

“My Congressman supports repealing Obamacare but not defund….”

It is wonderful that Congressmen support repealing Obamacare, but it’s not enough.  The House has had numerous votes to repeal Obamacare, but the chances of statutorily repealing the law decreased once President Obama won a second term.  Conservatives cannot wait another three-and-a-half years to begin dismantling Obamacare; they need to leverage current opportunities to defund Obamacare on “must-pass” spending bills.

“Since Obamacare is the President’s ‘signature achievement’ won’t he veto any effort to defund the program?  Why should conservatives make this the focus of their anti-Obamacare efforts?”

There is a critical window of opportunity to stop the flow of funding for Obamacare from now until October 1, 2013, when the new fiscal year begins.  It is during the same window that the President and Congress must pass bills to fund the government for the coming year.  It is entirely appropriate for conservative members of Congress to use this opportunity to say, “No more funding for Obamacare!” and wage a serious and determined fight.   If the Republican House girds for this fight—and wins the national argument with the urgency coming from a number of scheduled implementation dates and the law’s rising unpopularity—President Obama will be forced to compromise.

“If you don’t have the votes for a statutory repeal, why would you think you can get the votes to defund Obamacare?”

The Constitution grants the House of Representatives the ultimate “power of the purse.”  If Congress chooses not to fund Obamacare activities for the upcoming fiscal year, the Obama Administration cannot act to implement the law.  The President’s party does not control the House of Representatives, which must originate debt limit and spending bills to fund the government.  And the House Republican Majority was elected in 2010, on the basis of its platform against Obamacare.

“Won’t adding a provision to defund Obamacare to a ‘must-pass’ appropriations bill lead to a government shutdown?”

Obviously, this will set up a major political confrontation with President Obama, but it is the sort of conflict that will allow conservatives in the House of Representatives to remind the American people that the worst aspects of Obamacare are about to take hold and a defunding rider is the only thing standing in the way.

If House Republicans insist on defunding Obamacare, it is possible that the Obama Administration will shut the government down.  This would not be the end of the world, and it needs to be an option.  President Clinton shut the government down in 1995, by refusing to sign legislation to fund the government.  While most pundits in Washington DC believe that this was a catastrophic political failure for Republicans, it is a fact that the House Republicans maintained their majority in 1996, even with a popular president of another party on the ticket.  And their willingness to not accept all of Clinton’s demands was crucial towards eventually balancing the budget and reforming welfare.  The nation can no longer afford for conservatives to leave political leverage on the table.

“Shouldn’t Obamacare opponents focus instead on repealing pieces of the law where there is bipartisan support—for example, the medical device tax or the IPAB—in order to reinforce the fact that Obamacare is not set in stone and make its supporters take hard votes?”

Washington is filled with special interest groups lobbying everyday to secure a “fix” for the part of Obamacare that affects their industry.  There is no “fix” for this law and every time Congress caves to a special interest and makes the law “better” for that group, a little less momentum exists for full and final defunding or repeal.  “Fix” votes also give Obamacare supporters every opportunity to appear reasonable and willing to fix the worst excesses of the law.  The grim reality is that if the opponents of Obamacare are not willing to use every bit of political leverage at their disposal—a Republican majority in the House of Representatives, mostly made up of Congressmen from safe seats with constituents who strongly object to Obamacare—to halt implementation of the law, then it will be set in stone.  There is simply no more time, particularly as the massive exchange subsidies are made available and the Medicaid expansion takes effect.

LINK:  http://heritageaction.com/2013/07/defunding-obamacare-questions-ans...

CRENSHAW:

Please defund Obamacare
 
If Barack Obama threatens to shut down the government unless ObamaCare is fully funded, then call his bluff. Let him do it. The American people will not tolerate the spending of one more dime on the implementation of ObamaCare and over half the people in this country want this health care bill repealed.
 
Please stop capitulating, and looking for reasons not to do the right thing. Stop surrendering before the fight has begun. Support the call of Senators Mike Lee, Ted Cruz, Rand Paul and others to defund ObamaCare.
 
If there is a government shutdown, it won't be because conservatives refused to fund the government. It will be because Barack Obama is holding America hostage to an unpopular, unworkable "train wreck!"
 
This bill is going to hurt the most fragile citizens in our economy.  People like my sister whose small on line business has been hurt badly by the Obama administration's policies did not have an income large enough to purchase health insurance and now is making even less money (thanks to Obama) but does not qualify for a subsidy, because she isn't totally destitute yet.  Aside from damaging her ability to make the sales necessary to keep life and limb together, now the federal government will further punish her by fining her for not being able to purchase health insurance which could prevent her from going to and being able to pay her doctor if she needed to.  It is insane!  But I have watched this president implement one policy after another without any regard at all for middle America or the working poor until I have nothing but utter contempt for him.
 
Further, mark my words, if ObamaCare is fully implemented, patriotic Americans will not blame Barack Obama. Patriotic Americans will blame you and other responsible congressmen for failing to defund ObamaCare when they could have and still can.
 
Kind regards,
Bill Nelson:
If Barack Obama threatens to shut down the government unless ObamaCare is fully funded, then call his bluff. Let him do it. The American people will not tolerate the spending of one more dime on the implementation of ObamaCare and over half the people in this country want this health care bill repealed.
 
Please stop capitulating, and looking for reasons not to do the right thing. Support the call of fellow Senators like Mike Lee, Ted Cruz, Rand Paul and others to defund ObamaCare.
 
If there is a government shutdown, it won't be because congress refused to fund the government. It will be because Barack Obama is holding America hostage to an unpopular, unworkable "train wreck!"
 
This bill is going to hurt the most fragile citizens in our economy.  People like my sister whose small on line business has been hurt badly by the Obama administration's policies did not have an income large enough to purchase health insurance and now is making even less money, but does not qualify for a subsidy, because she isn't totally destitute yet.  Aside from damaging her ability to make a reasonable living to keep life and limb together, now the federal government will further punish her by fining her for not being able to purchase health insurance which could prevent her from going to and being able to pay her doctor if she needed to.  It is insane!  But I have watched this president implement one policy after another without any regard at all for middle America or the working poor until I have nothing but utter contempt for him.
 
Further, mark my words, if ObamaCare is fully implemented, patriotic Americans will not blame Barack Obama. Patriotic Americans will blame you and other responsible congressmen for failing to defund ObamaCare when they could have and still can.
 
Kind regards,

Views: 42

Comment

You need to be a member of First Coast Tea Party to add comments!

Join First Coast Tea Party

Comment by Patricia M. McBride on August 6, 2013 at 6:44am

I find your comments very interesting.  In what ways do you find the tea party to be like the republican party?   I wish we had started this conversation sooner.  There are 5 or 6 of us that are going up to Yulee together to the meeting for Common Core and we are car pooling.  You might have gone with us (we are meeting at my house at 10:30 this morning).  I think the conversation on the ride up might have been quite interesting as we have some folks who speak their minds as you do.   If you would like to come and can do it on such short notice, please let me know. 

Comment by Patricia M. McBride on August 5, 2013 at 6:46am

Franklin, it is busy, and there is a great deal going on.  We have groups walking and knocking on doors and many groups are active and engaged.  Not all the members of our group come to the web site (in fact, few of them do) which is why most of my info is sent to them via Email or phone calls.   What meeting did you go to that you felt was not well received and when?  During the summer months, there is a tendency towards less response just because it is summer and many people travel.  Did you talk to the team leader?  The team leader might have been able to answer some of these questions for you.

National Debt Clock

  

The First CoastTea Party is a non-profit organization. We have no deep-pocketed special interest funding our efforts.

You may contact us at:

First Coast Tea Party
1205 Salt Creek Island Dr
Ponte Vedra, FL 32082
904-392-7475

Helpful Links

Blog Posts

Collecting for our Bahamian Neighbors

Good morning!

We spent last week wondering if we would be hit by Hurricane Dorian.  Thankfully we were spared.  However, the Bahamas were not so lucky.  I am sure you have seen the devastation there.

My daughter has a friend (a nurse) who is arranging multiple trips to the area and will be collecting supplies to take to those areas.  If you would like to help, we will collect things at…

Continue

Posted by Babs Jordan on September 6, 2019 at 9:38am — 1 Comment

© 2020   Created by LeadershipCouncil.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service